The World As it Is vs. the World As it Should Be

It is a tension that has confounded people for centuries:  ‘the world as it is’ vs. ‘the world as it should be’.   Most people make some commitment to doing something that will help bring about the world as it should be, but their commitment may falter, or may even be abandoned, because of the overwhelming stress, if not despair, over the world as it is. 

Every religious expression that I know about stakes out a vision of a world as it should be.   In spite of their many differences in history and wide variations in symbol, narrative and practice, there are common threads that are universally embraced across the religious continuum:  peace, justice, hope, love.  Each religion has carved out a unique pathway for achieving the world as it should be.

A growing number of people have been disillusioned by religion, to the degree that – for some, any religious perspective is dismissed as overly sentimental, too judgmental – or so far removed from the world as it is (particularly given the many advances of science) that religion is little more than a caricature. 

I was a Religion major in college.  One of the first things I learned in my studies is to come to terms with what religion is not.  My most important early teachers in this were Karl Marx and Sigmund Freud.  Marx described religion as the “opiate of the people”, as it offers endless addictive bromides to people who couldn’t otherwise escape from the inequities of a capitalist system – from the world as it is.  Freud maintained that religion was the psyche’s attempt to escape the pain of relationships by projecting a pie-in-the sky set of beliefs that were totally disconnected from reality (the world as it is).

I agreed with them as a college sophomore, and I agree with them still.  Religion – especially when it distorts or denies reality, and/or exclusively engages people in the world as it should be, runs counter to the Latin root of the word religion:  religio, which refers to the symbols, practices and stories that bind people together.  As opposed to pulling them apart.

And we have a lot of religious, and certainly political, forces that are pulling people apart, by demonstrating a deeply held commitment to have people limit their lives and their perspectives to the world as it should be – as they define it.  There are growing efforts to deny the world as it is:  be it the existence of transgender persons or the painful and brutal history of race, or the continuing saga of racial inequity.  Or locking up criminals (and, as some would suggest, throwing away the key), as a way of getting rid of the “criminal element”, leaving the rest to live in the world as it should be. 

And on the other end of a religious and political spectrum, there are many for whom a world as it should be is one where there are no guns; when in reality (the world as it is) there are over 400 million guns in over one third of the households in America.  Guns have been part of the American landscape from the beginning; they are not going away.

Where religion – and politics, are most effective – and needed, is when they can arrive at some integration between ‘the world as it is’ and ‘the world as it should be’.  Honoring injustice, pain and despair while at the same time offering hope, peace, blessing and love.  The two circles of the ‘world as it is’ and ‘the world as it should be’, need to intersect.  They can never be completely separate, nor can they completely overlap.  They live in tension, a tension which ultimately is creative and life giving.  The intersecting circles form a mandorla, which is the Italian word for almond. (and is pictured in this post’s graphic)  It is the space of where hope and pain meet, where joy and sorrow can flow in and out of each other.  It is a space we should seek.

 

Recent Posts

Intellectual Scrutiny vs. Religious Expression

Intellectual Scrutiny vs. Religious Expression

“While in college, his Jesuit formation did not stand up to intellectual scrutiny.”  So said the introduction to my college’s new president in the Alumni magazine published several decades ago.  Intellectual rigor won out over religious expression.  Again. By the time...

Survival of the Fittest and Silicon Valley Bank

Survival of the Fittest and Silicon Valley Bank

Survival of the fittest is an adage that has long been planted in our psyches.  The phrase emerged as a terse summary of Charles Darwin's findings that the strongest and fittest of a species have the best chance of passing their genes on to the next generation.  The...

Pride:  a Refusal to Accept our Limitations

Pride: a Refusal to Accept our Limitations

I have not been one who has subscribed to the notion of original sin, which is the legacy Christians have inherited from Adam and Eve, whom the Judeo-Christian tradition have identified as the first man and first woman.  We meet them in the Garden of Eden, which is...

The Journey From the Ego to the Soul

The Journey From the Ego to the Soul

The fear mongers and the anger entrepreneurs are ubiquitous. Their messages — on air, screen or in print, are intended to arouse the ego and trigger a reaction. Fill us with resentment, indignation or fear. Concepts and issues that had once invited conversation are...

The Fault Line of Woke

The Fault Line of Woke

There are some serious, if not dangerous, fault lines in American discourse these days.  Some have been around for decades – notably attitudes toward guns and abortion;  and we take care to avoid these issues or tread lightly around them in conversation with people...

Intellectual Scrutiny vs. Religious Expression

“While in college, his Jesuit formation did not stand up to intellectual scrutiny.”  So said the introduction to my college’s new president in the Alumni magazine published several decades ago.  Intellectual rigor won out over religious expression.  Again. By the time...

Survival of the Fittest and Silicon Valley Bank

Survival of the fittest is an adage that has long been planted in our psyches.  The phrase emerged as a terse summary of Charles Darwin's findings that the strongest and fittest of a species have the best chance of passing their genes on to the next generation.  The...

Pride: a Refusal to Accept our Limitations

I have not been one who has subscribed to the notion of original sin, which is the legacy Christians have inherited from Adam and Eve, whom the Judeo-Christian tradition have identified as the first man and first woman.  We meet them in the Garden of Eden, which is...

The Journey From the Ego to the Soul

The fear mongers and the anger entrepreneurs are ubiquitous. Their messages — on air, screen or in print, are intended to arouse the ego and trigger a reaction. Fill us with resentment, indignation or fear. Concepts and issues that had once invited conversation are...

The Fault Line of Woke

There are some serious, if not dangerous, fault lines in American discourse these days.  Some have been around for decades – notably attitudes toward guns and abortion;  and we take care to avoid these issues or tread lightly around them in conversation with people...

The Disabling Debate on Freedom of Speech

Free speech, which most people in America recognize as a fundamental right, is undergoing endless and painful scrutiny these days.  What opinions should be allowed – or prohibited, on Facebook or Twitter?  When do stated certain political or religious convictions...

The Killing of Tyre Nichols: An Eruption of Violence

If you haven’t seen the video, you certainly have heard about the savage beating of Tyre Nichols, which led to his death,  murder charges brought against five Memphis police offers who carried out the atrocity, and their subsequent firing. Brutal, horrific, evil.  And...

The Confounding Paradox of the Gun Divide

In the wake of 40 mass shootings so far this January, I am struck by – and stuck on, some paradoxical statements that have echoes in different parts of the country.  The first, from Shannon Watts, who is the founder of Moms Demand Action, a gun violence prevention...

Dr. Martin Luther King: Joining Holiness and Justice

Our country pauses today to honor the memory and challenge of the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.  We remember him as a prophet for civil rights who, throughout his public ministry, dared to bend the arc of history toward justice. But it didn’t start out that way.  As...

Lament: A More Effective Way to Deal with Outrage

Like most of us, my first reaction upon hearing of a six-year-old boy shooting his teacher with a gun at Richneck Elementary School in Newport News, Virginia, was outrage.  How can a six-year-old get a gun?  How does he know how to use it?  How is he supervised?  How...
Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join my mailing list to receive the latest blog updates.

You have Successfully Subscribed!