I Versus We

Some fifty years ago, The Episcopal Church, along with many other Christian denominations, went through a liturgical upgrade.  The Nicene Creed, which was first written in 325 during the Council of Nicea (and from which its name is derived), and which is said at most every worship service, was significantly revised.  The Creed was transformed from being an individual statement of faith –  “I believe”, to a communal proclamation – “we believe”;  which reflected the commitment that the church was indeed a community of faith; that members should work together; that parishioners are accountable to one another. 

This change from I to we didn’t sit well with everyone.  There was a woman, Dottie, in one congregation I served, who refused to adapt.  Every time the phrase “we believe” came up in the Nicene Creed (six times, including at the very beginning) she would loudly and defiantly say “I believe” a half a beat before the congregational chorus got there.  It threw everyone off; except Dottie. She soldiered on.  Invitations to get her to at least say her statement in concert with everyone else were rebuffed; appeals to the notion that we aspired to be a community of faith; that we were, in fact, a “we”, were met with louder defiance.

In the thirty years since I served that New Jersey congregation, I haven’t met anyone who has repeated Dottie’s weekly one-woman protest.  At least not in church.  But there is a growing number of groups and individuals –  those who champion individualism, who are showing up everywhere else.  In his book, The Upswing, sociologist Robert Putnam offers reams of evidence that America has moved from a “we” culture to an “I” culture.  That we live in a world in which a person’s individual rights are paramount and should not – and must not, be challenged or violated.

I hear this often in my conversations with people who are deeply committed to their right to purchase, carry, and display guns.  Staunch defenders of the second amendment, they see any attempt to reform gun laws as an assault on their individual freedom.  Yet I find that there is a glaring inconsistency in this position, because many in this same cohort are just as passionate about denying people on the other side of the political spectrum their individual right to consider having an abortion.  The insistence to protect the I culture on guns devolves into a we culture in their relentless commitment to protect what they refer to as the unborn.  We end up with a tribal bubble: don’t you dare tread on any of us inside, but we can tread heavily on those on the outside.

There is at least one other tribal bubble that is emerging – and that has similar inconsistencies.  There is growing cohort of Americans who resist claiming any religious identity.  That their spiritual orientation is deeply personal, and any theology, ideology or practice should not – and must not, be imposed.  As this anti-religious I culture continues to develop, within it there is a growing tendency to identify religious people as rigid and wrong.  Religious people are either shamed or deemed to be irrelevant.  Don’t tread on any of us inside, but we can make all sorts of judgments on those on the outside.

These bubbles are being fortified by no end of forces and voices.  There is an impulse, from both sides, to burst these bubbles – to vanquish the other side.  The destruction that would follow would be unimaginable.  Instead of bursting bubbles, they need to be brought together – into the mandorla

Into the intersection between two circles where common ground can be found.  Into a space where transformation can happen; and where new perspectives can emerge.  It takes courage to enter the mandorla space.  When I have proposed this to people —  in either of these two bubbles, the reaction from some is strikingly similar:  if I step into the mandorla and seek to listen and try to understand people in the other bubble, I will be betraying my values.  What is not said, but nevertheless implied, if I venture to understand the other bubble, I will be committing spiritual, intellectual and tribal treason. 

My response:  get over it. 

As we move deeper into the election season, and the tension continues to ratchet up and the polarization becomes even more intractable, we need engage the courage to build bridges, establish relationships, and dare to listen beneath tropes, memes and sound bytes.  To commit to building a we culture.  We cannot force people into the mandorla. That won’t work.  And yes, there are some people who are so embedded in their respective bubbles that they refuse to move.  The Dotties of the world will continue to speak out of turn.  We can work ourselves up in frustration over their intransigence.  Get over it.  They won’t change.  There is other work to do.  We can change – and often we need to force ourselves into that mandorla space.  It is hard.  We need help – from each other.  To move out from I into we.  And trust that our collective efforts can make a difference.

What Do The Risks of Aleksei Navalny and Jesus Say to Us?

When Aleksei Navalny returned to Russia from Germany in January 2021 after recovering from being poisoned, prison was certain and death was likely.   Navalny died on Friday, February 16 at the IK-3 Penal Colony, located 1200 miles northeast of Moscow in the arctic...

Aging, the Election and a Pathway Through the Chaos

Are Joe Biden and Donald Trump too old to be President?  This question is getting a lot of attention, with no end of commentary.  Assessments are being made as to each candidate’s physical stamina, mental acuity, and psychological health.  Recommendations have been...

Immigration: Moving Beyond Technical Fix to Adaptive Challenge

In 2013 I spent a couple of days at the southern border with a group of fellow bishops.  We stayed in Douglas Arizona, but several times made our way through the checkpoint into Agua Prieta, Mexico.  A small group of us helped deliver water to the several water tanks...

From a Dentist’s Chair: Musings on Vulnerability

Last week I sat for two hours in a periodontist’s office while receiving a dental implant.  My mouth was adequately and expertly numbed, and the only discomfort I felt was the anxiety I experienced when the periodontist began to drill into my jawbone.  There was not...

Ep 10 – “How We Learn to Be Brave” with Bishop Mariann Budde

We discuss the process of discernment in decisive moments in life and faith, and how God calls us to be brave in such moments.

Ep 9 – “Following the Way of Jesus” with Pastor Raymond Chang

We discuss the roots of Ray’s faith commitment, the origins and nature of his work to prevent gun violence and racialized violence, current events in Israel and Palestine, and the role of reconciliation in all of this.

Stepping Out of Fear and Into Light and Hope

It was someone else’s story, but over the years I have retold it as if it has become my own.  It was Gardner Taylor’s story, which he told at the end of a sermon during my first year of divinity school, nearly fifty years ago.  Dr. Taylor was then the pastor of...

Ep 8 – “Finding Solutions Together” with Angela Ferrell-Zabala

Our discussion touches on faith and love for our neighbors and Angela shares the powerful example and influence of her mother on her life.

Where Does Evil Come From? How Best to Deal with It?

Several years ago, while still an active bishop, I facilitated a meeting that I suspected would not go well.  It didn’t.  People, including me, came in angry or scared – or both.  Half the group resisted the agenda, and the other half resented the resisters.   Nearly...

Our Shared Humanity is Threatened by Fear and a Siege Mentality

The challenge, Henri Nouwen said in a class I took with him nearly fifty years ago, is not to see how we are different, but how we are the same.  Yes, there are differences, he acknowledged – gender, age, culture, race, religion, life experience; but at root we all...
Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join my mailing list to receive the latest blog updates.

You have Successfully Subscribed!