Teach Us to Care and Not to Care: T.S. Eliot

It is becoming harder and harder to achieve emotional, spiritual and in some cases physical distance from what is happening in this country.  I hear more and more people saying that they are reluctant to buy, sell or make changes to their home because the economy is so labile.  People whose status as Americans in uncertain or tentative – or being challenged – are trying to hide out of sight in fear because the immigration and citizenship process has become so capricious and cruel.  And more and more people are afraid to speak or write about some of their concerns because their remarks may lead to some sort of indictment.

So many of us are living in a swirl of fear, anger, outrage, and resentment that at moments it feels as though we are being suffocated.  It is hard to breathe when the airwaves are filled with such vitriol and vengeance, and we are being confronted with such naked attempts to achieve domination.

What we need in the face of the rise of autocracy and the dismantling of democracy is an emotional and spiritual oxygen mask or ventilator.  And we have them. They are not physical, but existential, and they can be soul saving.  Nearly 100 years ago, poet T.S. Eliot wrote Ash Wednesday (1930), shortly after he converted to Anglicanism (which is where I make my spiritual home).  In the poem he wrote – twice – “teach us to care and not to care.”  The implication for me in our current situation is that Eliot is calling me to make an important separation between the tornado of feelings generated by all the chaos, corruption, incompetence, lack of compassion, and disregard of due process and the rule of law, on the one hand; and the issues that all the executive orders affect on the other.  We need to care about those issues – human rights, economic inequality, the growing acceptance of racial prejudice and racism, incivility, climate change, the attempt to rework American history – and on and on — and do what we can to protest the illegality, protect the vulnerable, and witness to justice. 

The effects of the avalanche, tornado, tsunami, volcanic eruption – choose your metaphor because they all apply – are life denying.  Eliot’s poem is also challenging us to not care about them, or at least care less about them, because when we do so we are then better enabled to be more attentive to and effective with the issues that the Trump administration is taking on.

There is a spiritual discipline that I have found to be a kind of spiritual ventilator that helps me breathe amid the swirl.  It is an act of oblation.  Oblation refers to a prayerful offering to a god or spirit.  It is an act of giving, or more particularly, giving over.  I physically extend my arms with upturned palms in a calisthenic of offering.  Occasionally I audibly identify what I am giving over:  “here, take this.  It is too much for me.”  Most of the time I am silent, but with a clear internal intention of what I want to turn over.  Does it work? I can’t say for sure, but in some confidence – mixed with faith – I can say it is working, provided I keep offering it, sometimes several times a day. I am breathing better. I am finding that I am less constricted by the chaos, and more focused and committed to preserving the democracy that is being ruthlessly threatened. I am learning to care and not to care. My oblation is to a God with whom I have had a lifelong relationship. Others may give their offering to a spirit – or to the universe, depending on their religious faith or lack of same.  In any case, the oblation is to a capacious space that can receive it, providing some distance from the chaos, at the same time freeing us up to do the important work that is before us. We all need to keep at it, trusting that it will open us up to grace, mercy and, for some of us, God’s loving presence.

The Bible demonstrates to me that creativity can come out of chaos if – and this is a big if, we can live into the paradox of standing in the chaos while at the same time having some distance from it.  President Trump is a master not only at creating chaos, but ensnaring – and spiritually paralzying – people in it.  That is his perverse strength.  We have options and resources to help lead us through all the turbulence so we can help restore, and build, a more perfect Union.  Engage them.

 

 

 

Facing Down a Crusade

“…Trumpism is a thoroughly religious movement”, David French wrote in a November 16 op-ed in the New York Times. A self-described evangelical Christian, French went on to say that since Trumpism is a religious phenomenon, it requires a religious answer. I agree. And...

Gratitude: The Foundation of Thanksgiving

A national day of Thanksgiving was first declared by President Abraham Lincoln in 1863, to be observed at the end of the harvest season, in late November. Over the decades the date moved around several times, and in 1942 President Franklin Roosevelt issued a...

Invitation to an online pre-Thanksgiving event on Sunday evening

WELCOME TO THANKSGIVING VOICES A Braver Faith National Event Sunday, November 23, 2025 Time: 4 PM PT | 5 PM MT | 6 PM CT | 7 PM ET   Join us for an evening of gratitude and reflection as we hear from voices representing diverse faith traditions. The webinar will...

Hope: An Antidote to Getting Hooked

“Beware of getting hooked,” a trusted friend and colleague advised me when I asked her what to watch out for when I was moving to a new position, a new city, a new life. “You have a tendency to get hooked by people who get under your skin because of the pain they live...

The Challenge to Claim our Ground, Our Humus

A challenge for all of us these days, regardless of where we fall on the political or religious continuum, is to stay grounded. Feet and soul firmly planted on terra firma. We are buffeted about by so many opinions, orders, actions and reactions– mostly framed in...

Exile. Lament. Love. Repeat. A sequence I have settled on to help me deal with the chaos and cruelty that is swirling around us and raising havoc within us. Certainly around and within me. Exile. Exile involves being barred or sent away from one’s country. That is...

Responding to the de facto Congress with Power Rather than Resentment

We have a new de facto Congress. It has not been voted in by various constituencies across the country, but it has been elected. By one person -- the President. The qualifications for this rump Congress are becoming increasingly clear: loyalty and wealth.The...

Agape Love: A Political Act

As vengeance, threats of violence, and vilification continue to take over the airwaves – and increasingly get deployed on many of our city streets – there is an ever more urgent need to expand the concept of love. Not only to expand it, but empower love to wade into...

The Need to Put on a Life-Giving Mask

As an airplane taxis toward takeoff, I invariably treat the mandatory instruction from the flight attendant as annoying background noise: “Make sure you put your own oxygen mask on before assisting others”. Most of us don’t pay any attention, because we figure such a...

Responding to Those Who are Itching for a Fight

A vivid memory burst into my consciousness a few days ago, which has, for me, a direct connection to the recent deployment of the National Guard in several US cities.Several years ago I was sitting at the old Yankee Stadium, attending a Red Sox-Yankee game. My friends...
Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join my mailing list to receive the latest blog updates.

You have Successfully Subscribed!