The Challenges of Freedom

Freedom.  The bedrock of the American experiment.  It is protected in the first amendment of the Bill of Rights, adopted in 1791:  freedom to exercise one’s religion, freedom of speech, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly, freedom of the right to petition the government for redress of grievances.  These freedoms are enshrined because they weren’t available under colonial rule.

We cherish freedom.  We celebrate freedom.  And yet – we are increasingly challenged by various paradoxes that the concept of freedom generates.  Two glaring examples stand out:  the substantial minority in this country, who are highly organized and well-funded, who insist on the freedom to buy, carry, and use a gun – without hindrance.  And the majority of Americans who insist that a woman should have the freedom to determine whether or not to bring a pregnancy to term.  What has emerged over the decades – and now is reaching full crescendo – is a paralyzing polarization in which people are fighting against someone else’s freedom – to either own, carry or use a gun; or to have an abortion.

As more and more people seem to be locked down and closed-up on these two – and other issues, the idea of freedom has been reduced to a parochial value and a tribal rallying cry. 

And freedom suffers as a result.

Most of us have felt pressured to make a choice as to which silo, which tribe, we want to join.  And to feel compelled to adopt the metaphors and messages of that group, accompanied by an expectation that we will adopt the identity of that silo, tribe, ideology, or party.  Over the years I have heard many people identify themselves as Christian, and refer to other people — “He/she is a Christian.”  The identifications are clear — as are the implications:  Christians are those who claim a prescribed set of beliefs and and engage in a particular practice — and those of us who  may have lived a lifetime of faith and discipline, with a different theology and kind of engagement, are not considered to be fully Christian.  That may not be overtly said, but after hearing these conversations so often, it is how I usually feel.  Despite my baptism, ordination as priest and later as bishop, and regardless of my lifetime of seeking to follow the witness and teaching of Jesus, I am led to believe that I don’t make the cut.  That I don’t fit.

These harsh distinctions are not limited to the religious arena.  Increasingly, businesses and educational institutions are embracing training in diversity, equity and inclusion — DEI.  The intention is to invite students, teachers and colleagues to discover the roots of prejudice and racism, how they hinder the flourishing of schools, universities and workplaces; and how people and institutions can move forward if they confront some destructive historical patterns.  A laudable and indeed necessary goal.  But what many people are experiencing is a veiled form of coercion, which undercuts freedom — which in some cases are reinforcing some of the prejudices that the training programs are trying to address.  In a May 15 New York Times article, some of these important initiatives are revising their curricula — calling them Diversity, Equity and BELONGING.  Acknowledging that everyone on the ladder — whether from the top or the bottom, is part of the process.  No one is excluded. 

To my mind, which has been largely shaped by my religious journey, freedom is generative.  It moves outward.  It needs to include everyone.  Limiting freedom to an ideology or race or economic status is not freedom; it is security posing as freedom.  True freedom is excruciatingly difficult to achieve.  It involves opening hearts and expanding horizons.  It means engaging in contentious issues — like guns and abortion, with a willingness to listen and learn, rather than to insult or shame. 

Creating freedom is hard work.  There are times when it is just too hard, or not worth the effort.  Or it feels too difficult to sort through the challenge of discerning freedom from protection.  Those who insist on an absolute freedom to own, carry or use guns are, to my mind, not on a journey to freedom but instead display a fierce determination to secure tribal borders.  And need to be challenged.  Those who are virulently opposed to abortion, and seek to thwart women from having any freedom of choice in determining the course of their pregnancy are, to my mind, seeking to shore up their silo.  And need to be challenged.

Arriving at freedom was a challenge when our country was created and the Bill of Rights were written.  It still is, some 237 years later.

It is work we are called to do.

Emerging Moral Obscenity

It is a moral obscenity.  It is said by some that white Afrikaners in South Africa are the victims of genocide, but there is no data to support the claim. It is said that the cohort of Afrikaners coming to America are refugees, but there are indications that they are...

The Ordering of Love: a New Debate in the Culture Wars

Several decades ago, a national debate raged over a question that helped launch America’s ongoing culture war:  who can you love? One side was insistent that love – which would involve intimate sexual expression – should be confined to a man and a woman. A popular...

Make America Great Again: A Clamping Down on Paradigm Shift

In April of 1970 the United States decided to invade Cambodia, thus expanding the Vietnam War. I was nearing the end of my freshman year in college. Campuses around the country rose up in angry indignation. Protests were planned, strikes were proposed, marches were...

Teach Us to Care and Not to Care: T.S. Eliot

It is becoming harder and harder to achieve emotional, spiritual and in some cases physical distance from what is happening in this country.  I hear more and more people saying that they are reluctant to buy, sell or make changes to their home because the economy is...

Ep 22 – “The Greatest Unifier” with Rick Joyner

In this episode, I welcome Rick Joyner, a prominent Evangelical leader, author, public speaker, and founder of Morningstar Ministries. We explore how to respectfully build mutual understanding and work together across differences. Rick shares about his life-changing conversion, his strong support for President Trump, his belief in God as the greatest unifier, and the challenges and hopes that he sees for the country. We also discuss finding unity in diversity and the ongoing pursuit of liberty and justice for all.

Fossil Fuels, Easter, and Pope Francis

For more than two hundred years we have been pulling former life out of the ground to heat our buildings, power our cars, run our machines, illuminate our lights. Fossil fuels, so named because they are the remnants of plants, animals and living microbes which, over...

Palm Sunday: Two Very Different Demonstrations of Power

They came into the city through separate gates, almost at the same time. The first was a procession that demonstrated power: Pontius Pilate’s power, backed by all the forces of the Roman Empire. The second procession was smaller, feeble by comparison, and it...

Personal and Systemic Racism: A Critical Difference

“Personal racism has gone down”, a wise colleague told me recently, “but institutional racism has gone up.” This is both good and bad news.The good news is that over the decades of my lifetime more and more people have become increasingly sensitive to the issues of...

Privilege Can Drown Out Pain

“The secret to white privilege is that if you don’t want to hear something, you don’t have to,”  my mentor Ed Rodman said in a video retrospective:  “A Prophet Among Us”...

Dealing with Psychic Lactic Acid

I was about six strokes from the finish of a 100 yard butterfly race in an age-group competition this past weekend when my arms gave out.  The last two strokes looked like I was drowning. I could barely get my arms out of the water.  Fifty-five years ago I was a...
Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join my mailing list to receive the latest blog updates.

You have Successfully Subscribed!