Fighting Insults and Condemnation with the Power of Love

We were at the breakfast table.  My daughter, then about a year and a half, was in her highchair, scrambled eggs on the tray in front of her.  With an impish grin, she threw some of her meal on the floor.  “Don’t do that,” I said in a rather stern tone.  With an even larger grin, she threw some more eggs on the floor.  Immediately, and without thinking, I chided her: “Bad girl”, I said, raising my voice.  Her mother, who was thinking, just as quickly chided me: “She is not bad”; she may have done a bad thing, but she is not bad.”

Oh, I thought.  Right.  I apologized to my daughter, and vowed that I would try and never make the mistake of ascribing a person’s value to their behavior again.  I’m not sure I have succeeded.  Making unintentional (or intentional) moral judgments about people’s essential goodness on the basis of their actions has been part of family dynamics for as long as they have gathered at the kitchen table.  It is hard to give up the free-wheeling judgments and chastisements.  It can be satisfying to feel morally righteous and verbally punishing at the same time.  Separating personhood out from behavior can seem overly complicated.  ‘Bad girl’ is much easier.

Our public spaces are becoming filled with insults and outrage.  People’s very nature are venomously impugned on a daily basis.  Donald Trump has built his career on conflating a person’s essence with their behavior.  And he does it with a vengeance of regularity and intensity.  Various archivists have inventoried some 5,000 insults that he has written or said over the past few years.  ‘Bad girl’ or bad boy’, are not on the list, but loser, deranged, wack job, disgrace, crazy, crooked, joke, clown, are; not to mention a trove of unprintable invectives that have been blurted out from unmiked conversations.

There are at least three common responses to such put-downs:  disregard them, because they just keep coming at us like a broken fire hydrant; cower in their wake with shame, guilt or fear (or a combination of all three); or fight back.  The insulters of the world count on their targets responding in the first two ways:  the insults are like bad elevator music that can be ignored; or people are so afraid of the bullying that any overt reaction to it will be seen as an invitation to ramp up the cruelty.

Yet fighting back can also be a problem.  The impulse is to hit back at the putdown with the same level of animosity.  The insult itself is an invitation to violence; a commensurate response almost guarantees some form of violence.  Greater mistrust is the byproduct, and enmity can often result, all of which makes it easier to paint the person’s very soul with the brush of disdain.

That doesn’t mean we can’t fight.  But it does mean we need to fight with nonviolence.  And to fight with love.  Love is more than a feeling.  It is an act of the will.  It is the conviction that everyone deserves to receive the blessing of God, or if not God, than the blessing of humanity.  It takes work. Love can be confrontational without being insulting or inciting violence. 

Love is fierce.

One of the best depictions of this fierce love is outlined in the ‘Grand Inquisitor’, which is a poem/story contained within The Brothers Karamazov,  the 1880 novel by Fyodor Dostoevsky. The story is told by Ivan Karamazov to his younger brother Alyosha.  The story, which is described as a poem, takes place during the Spanish Inquisition in the 1660’s.  Jesus has returned, is arrested for performing miracles, and sentenced to be burned at the stake.  The grand inquisitor is a 90 year old church leader who chides Jesus for not giving in to the temptations posed by the devil:  to turn stones into bread, to demonstrate spectacular power, and to rule the earth.  (Matthew 4:1-11)  If Jesus had yes to those temptations, the inquisitor argues, people would have fully accepted his authority, and would become docile and happy, and would no longer experience suffering. ‘You gave them freedom of choice’, the old monk says, ‘and people can’t handle freedom.  They need to be ruled,and told what to do and think.  And to be punished severely when they transgress.  That will keep them in line, and render them obedient, docile and happy.’

Jesus remains silent.  When the condemnation is finished, Jesus approaches the Grand Inquisitor, kisses him on his “bloodless, aged lips”– and leaves the prison. Love prevails.  It is not destroyed.  Love has power.  Love invites freedom. Love can and needs to be fierce.

Martin Luther King captured this fierceness in one of his blessings: “ Power without love is reckless and abusive.  Love without power is sentimental and anemic.  Power at its best is love implementing the demands of justice, and justice at its best is power correcting anything that stands against love.”

Fight with love.  Let us use its prevailing and abiding power.

 

 

The Ten Commandments: Laws or Guidelines

Last week the governor of Louisiana signed a law mandating that the Ten Commandments be displayed in public school classrooms.  In some ways I get it, in spite of the fact that like so many it challenges the constitutional separation of church and state.  The Ten...

Mistrust and Trust

It was the spring of 1970.  The United States had just announced that it was expanding the war in Vietnam by authorizing bombing campaigns in Cambodia.  Campuses across the country erupted in protest.  On May 4, four protesting students at Kent State were shot and...

Challenges to Trusting the Process

Trust the process. This was a phrase I often heard when a strategy session or a problem-solving meeting bogged down.   The group would get stuck, and in frustration someone would either suggest we scrap the whole enterprise, or would start accusing a participant of...

Ep 13 – “A Common Humanity” with Wilk Wilkinson

Wilk Wilkinson joins me to discuss his journey from political apathy to toxic political engagement, followed by the epiphany that since led him on a mission of bettering the world, one attitude at a time, by charting a course toward understanding, bridging divides, and fostering a community where wisdom prevails over discord.

Time and Space Needed for Grief and Mourning

“In war, death interrupts nothing.  Time doesn’t stop; it seems to accelerate.”  So wrote David French, in a New York Times column on May 25, 2024.  A veteran of the Iraq War, French goes on to say that in battle there is no time or space for mourning the loss of a...

Whose Land is It?

A couple of weeks ago, I came across this passage from my daily reading:     “From the wilderness and the Lebanon as far as the great river, the river Euphrates,all the land of the Hittites, to the Great Sea in the west shall be your territory.   No one will be able...

Ep 12 – “The Church Cracked Open” with The Rev. Canon Stephanie Spellers

Canon Spellers shares her journey from being a skeptic and critic of the Church to becoming a senior leader with a deep faith and a commitment to social justice. We explore the themes of mission, evangelism, the power of genuine curiosity in bridging divides, and ongoing efforts to address systemic issues like white supremacy within the church.

Dealing With Fear

Tornados of fear are swirling around the world, many of them invading our psyches.  Wars in Ukraine and Gaza, not to mention Sudan and Myanmar; escalating climate change; unrelenting gun violence; immigration crises.  To my mind, the storms of fear are particularly...

The Different Layers of Campus Anger

I lived a block away from a campus protest that erupted in November, 1974.  I was a teaching fellow at Doshisha University in Kyoto, Japan, and the campus was about to be shut down in opposition to Gerald Ford’s visit to the city, the first time an American President...

Campus Protests: What We Bring to What We See

In the past week I have had several conversations with friends about our respective opinions on what is happening on college campuses across the country, as students have set up encampments to protest the war in Gaza and insist that their university divest any...
Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join my mailing list to receive the latest blog updates.

You have Successfully Subscribed!